N. Scott Momaday: Literary Chieftain of a Native American
Renaissance

Kyungwon Lee
N. Scott Momaday: Literary Chieftain of a Native American Renaissance
Thesis: The cultural diversity of his childhood, destabilizing effects of American legislation on native cultures, environmental destruction of native lands, and political precedents of the 1960s fostered the development of N. Scott Momaday’s convictions in the environmental responsibility of mankind, power of language, and need for identity, all of which are presented in his Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, House Made of Dawn. While initially dismissed by some critics, the novel’s literary merit and impact upon the twentieth century cannot be ignored, for it shattered traditional Native American stereotypes, triggered a renewed interest in Native American cultures, advocated the fusion of Native and European American policies, and sparked what Kenneth Lincoln termed the “Native American Renaissance” (“N(avarre) Scott Momaday” par. 1).
I. Introduction
II. Biography and personal and social influences of Momaday
A. Heritage and childhood: Kiowa/Cherokee/European descent, multicultural experience, faced alienation and experienced cultural ambiguity
B. Indian legislation: Dawes Act, Relocation Act, loss of native lands, mandatory assimilation threatened the survival of native cultures
C. Environmental destruction: deterioration of ecosystems offended traditional beliefs of many Native Americans, extinction of the buffalo, pressures of consumerism
D. Political precedents: precedent from African American movement, American Indian Movement, pan-Indian political effort
III. Main arguments and rhetorical strategies
A. In his 1968 debut, House Made of Dawn, N. Scott Momaday laments the loss of environmental responsibility and showcases the power of language and the human need for identity.
B. Importance of the Preservation of Nature
1. Imagery portrays nature’s beauty (ex: eagles)
2. Tank symbolizes the destruction of the earth
1. Tosamah’s persona is used to relay Momaday’s views on language
2. Sacred language used to establish credibility and appeal to authority
3. Abel’s inarticulateness hampers his relationship with his native culture
1. Abel’s actions symbolize his alienation (ex: killing of the albino)
2. Abel vs. Francisco: juxtaposition illustrates Abel’s detachment
3. Application of oral tradition techniques
IV. Legacies of Momaday’s literature
A. Social redefinition: shattered Indian stereotypes, pushed for education for Native Americans, pioneered the field of Native American studies
B. Cultural revival: became unofficial figurehead for the Native American community (“voice”), public exposure brought recognition to Native Americans, founded the Buffalo Trust
C. Political impressions: encouraged Red Power movement, advocated the incorporation of the Native American land ethic into American policies
D. Literary impacts: sparked the Native American Renaissance, increased non-native interest in Native American literature, influenced Native American writers (Leslie Marmon Silko, Gerald Vizenor)
V. Conclusion
VI. Works Cited
N. Scott Momaday: Literary Chieftain of a Native American Renaissance
When asked about his childhood aspirations, N. Scott Momaday replied: “Oh, a cowboy” (“Shouting at the Machine” 126). An obvious jest from the Native American writer, the answer reflects Momaday’s confidence in his identity as an American Indian and lack of bitterness toward age-old race conflicts. Furthermore, the cultural diversity of his childhood, destabilizing effects of American legislation on native cultures, environmental destruction of native lands, and political precedents of the 1960s fostered the development of N. Scott Momaday’s convictions in the environmental responsibility of mankind, power of language, and need for identity, all of which are presented in his Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, House Made of Dawn. While initially dismissed by some critics, the novel’s literary merit and impact upon the twentieth century cannot be ignored, for it shattered traditional Native American stereotypes, triggered a renewed interest in Native American cultures, advocated the fusion of Native and European American policies, and sparked what Kenneth Lincoln termed the “Native American Renaissance” (“N(avarre) Scott Momaday” par. 1).
“I don’t know what an Indian
is. The ‘American Indian’—that term is
meaningless”
N.
Scott Momaday (Trimble 5).
From birth, Momaday’s rich medley of Kiowa, Cherokee, and
European blood, parental guidance, and early encounters with alienation
provided the basis for a unique cross-cultural perspective (“N(avarre) Scott Momaday”
par. 4).
His Kiowa father, Al Momaday, represented the dwindling number of
traditional—or “longhair”—Indians in
Due to his indigenous ancestry, legislation passed by the
United States government targeting Native Americans greatly shaped the world
that Momaday would inhabit in the mid-twentieth century. The General Allotment Act of 1887, more
commonly known as the Dawes Act, dismantled the very foundation of many tribal
cultures, including that of the Kiowas. The dissemination of communally held lands
and the corruption of traditional gender roles undermined tribal unity (Schubnell 27; “Native American
Cultures: Subsistence Patterns” par. 13). Mammedaty,
Momaday’s grandfather, was among the many demoralized former warriors and
hunters that were forced to adopt farming, a task customarily reserved for
women (Schubnell 27; “Native
American Cultures: Subsistence Patterns” par. 14). Government programs implemented in the 1950s
allowed Indians to relocate to prominent cities like
For millennia, the Native Americans regarded the land as “a
spiritual entity, the place of origin, source of subsistence, [and] home of
gods” (Schubnell
66).
Because of this reverence for the land, government policies aimed at
exploiting or annihilating nature were perceived as a direct assault on one of
the fundamental
principles
of many Native American tribes. Momaday
condemned the government’s endorsement of excessive hunting of the buffalo as
“perhaps the most immoral act ever committed against the land” (qtd. in Trimble 7). For the western tribes, the versatile buffalo
quickly gained ritual and sacred importance, ultimately becoming the natives’
“living shield” (“Native Americans of the Plains and Far West” par. 5; qtd. in Roemer par. 2). The collapse of buffalo populations due to
systematic hunting made subsistence economies unviable, forcing Native
Americans to become dependent on the government for sustenance and basic
supplies (Porter 52).
In the twentieth century, the land faced new threats from nuclear
testing, nuclear waste disposal, coal strip mining, and oil, logging, and
uranium extraction (40).
The transgressions of the past coupled with contemporary pressures urged
Momaday to promote a collaborative exchange and synthesis of beliefs between
native and white cultures for mutual benefit (Costo 4).
An era of hope for Native Americans in the 1960s encouraged
Momaday to take part in the growing social and political movement for Indian
rights and self-determination. By
the mid-1920s, the concept of cultural diversity had largely usurped the ideal
of the “American melting pot” (Porter 55). Activist groups such as the National Indian
Youth Council and the American Indian Movement (AIM), motivated by the
successes of the African American movement, advocated political sovereignty for
Native Americans and promoted cultural traditions as a source of pride (Teuton 3; “Native
American Movement” par. 4). The
founders of the AIM particularly emphasized the problems facing a growing
number of urban Indians, which included difficulty finding work, dilapidated
housing, low income, and police harassment and brutality (“Native
American Movement” par. 6). Momaday
would later depict these obstacles in House
Made of Dawn through the protagonist’s experiences in
“[I]n a certain sense we are all
made of words; […] our most essential being consists in language”
N. Scott Momaday (Schubnell 41).
In
his 1968 debut, House Made of Dawn,
Momaday laments the loss of environmental responsibility and showcases the
power of language and the human need for identity. Abel, the protagonist, is a young Native
American caught between a rapidly changing white society and a steadfastly
anachronistic tribal culture. House Made of Dawn chronicles Abel’s
spiritual return to the land of his ancestors in a classic oral setting, but
through an unorthodox medium: a novel.
This blending of indigenous and Euro-American mediums suggests that while
Momaday’s works are mainly credited with representing prominent Native American
principles, his views have greater universal appeal than one may expect. The protection of the land applies to all
humans and remains a pressing problem for the twenty-first century as
well. A respect for the art of language
has its roots in the oral tradition, but is similarly found in the scripture of
John in the Christian Bible (Bonetti
136-7). The necessity of identity
for individuals has also been expressed by a number of non-Indians, including
William Faulkner (Schubnell 68). These parallels between belief systems point
to Momaday’s ultimate goal of a union of cultures in American society.
Momaday’s stunning imagery and use of symbolism vividly conveys the beauty of the land and man’s failure to adequately preserve that beauty. In the prologue, Momaday deliberately orders the introduction of certain elements. The “old and everlasting” land is introduced first, followed by the spotted horses, and then the human, Abel (House Made of Dawn 1). By presenting the earth first, Momaday emphasizes the vast scale and magnificence of the land compared to the miniscule figure of Abel. From this perspective, man is demoted from the master to the servant of nature. Momaday exhibits nature’s beauty through the dazzling mating flight of the golden eagles. The eagles’ flight, described as “an awful, holy sight, full of meaning and magic,” absolutely mesmerizes Abel as he watches the spectacle:
They were cavorting, spinning and spiraling on the cold, clear columns of air, and they were beautiful. They swooped and hovered, leaning on the air, and swung close together, feinting and screaming with delight. (14, 16).
Momaday surpasses conventional methods of descriptive writing and employs the rhythms and cadences of the words themselves to mimic the sinuous movements of the eagles through the air (Lincoln 118). The use of fragmented syntax linguistically illustrates the currents and undulations of the eagles. Momaday contrasts this glorious display with the image of the “intrusion of the machine into the garden” to signify man’s sacrilege against the land (American Nature Writers par. 33). Later, while fighting in World War II, Abel witnesses the tank “rising up behind the hill, black and massive, looming there in front of the sun […] For a moment it seemed apart from the land” (House Made of Dawn 22). The obstruction of the sun and the darkness of the tank symbolize the imminent destruction of human kind. The disconnect between the machine and the land further warns of man’s departure from his roots in the earth. Through Abel’s interactions with nature, Momaday reveals the different aspects of man’s changing relationship with the earth.
In a setting where oral tradition is responsible for upholding a culture, words hold a special significance; they become “beings in themselves, incantatory, with spirits and bodies” (Costo 6; Lincoln 18). Momaday expresses these sentiments through the persona of Tosamah, an intellectual and peyote priest: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God” (House Made of Dawn 82). God, through the Word, was able to create the universe (Velie 27-28). Language has the power to create life, to fashion order out of chaos, to remove the mind from human limitations. The presence of precise sacred language also establishes credibility and gives authority to the novel. Momaday’s recitation of the immeasurably old Navajo chantway earns respect from his Native American audience (Scarberry-Garcia 8). The Navajo Night Chant also intimates that the source of Abel’s alienation is his loss of voice (Evers 39). Abel’s inability to express himself is especially tragic in his Native American setting. Only after the prayer where Abel asks, “Restore my voice for me,” can he acquire a sense of belonging and identity (Schubnell 40).
House Made of Dawn is
essentially the tale of Abel’s quest for spiritual identity. Although many of Abel’s voluntary actions
alienate him from his tribe, a number of sources of alienation are inherited
and predestined. Upon returning from the
war, the drunken Abel “fell against his grandfather and did not know him” (House Made of Dawn 8).
Abel’s inability to recognize his grandfather finalizes his spiritual
divorce from the tribe. Once Abel loses
his sense of identity, he becomes prone to drinking and violence. However, the sources of Abel’s alienation are
in his blood: “He did not know who his
father was. His father was a Navajo, they
said, or a Sia, or an Isleta, an outsider anyway,
which made him and his mother and Vidal somehow strange and foreign” (House Made of Dawn 11).
It is interesting to note that Abel’s mixed heritage is reminiscent of
Momaday’s own Kiowa-Cherokee ancestry.
Abel’s lack of understanding of tribal customs is demonstrated by his
murder of the albino (72-73). The albino, also called “the white man,” is
not quite a man, but a witch who embodies nothing but evil (qtd. in Velie 57). Francisco, the “longhair” grandfather, stands
in stark contrast to his confused and lost grandson. When Francisco senses the albino’s presence
in the cornfield, he chooses to bless the corn and continue with his work (House Made of Dawn 60).
Francisco’s acceptance of the unknown displays his understanding of the
natural place of evil in the world (Konevich par. 5). Momaday foreshadows Abel’s eventual return
by placing the novel within the setting of a classic native tale. Momaday uses the traditional Jemez Pueblo
words, “Dypaloh” and “Qtsedaba,”
at the beginning and end of the story to signify the formal application of oral
tradition techniques (Scarberry-Garcia
8). The structure of House Made of Dawn further reflects
native influences. The number four is
sacred to many tribes because it symbolizes balance and harmony (Allen 211). One will
notice that the novel is split into four sections and four main characters are
used to narrate the story (211). As Faulkner and Momaday both agree, man is
nothing without personal identity (Schubnell 68).
“[…] and this is why I paint and
write: I want to astonish God”
N. Scott Momaday (Prampolini 215).
While advocating Native American values, Momaday pursued a
subtle yet vital goal of demolishing longstanding stereotypes bestowed upon the
red race by the Great White Father.
For centuries, Native Americans were portrayed as “primitive, violent,
superstitious, backward, and inarticulate” (Velie 59).
However, Momaday’s literary talent, placid demeanor and optimistic
outlook convinced many to reevaluate that stereotype. Momaday’s writing provided realistic
characters that were neither “frozen in the nineteenth century” nor completely
severed from their native cultures (Allen 208). Education was a major element of Momaday’s
campaign for the successful renovation of the Native American persona. A critic once said: “American Indians do not write novels and
poetry as a rule or teach English at top ranking universities either, but we
can not be patronizing” (qtd. in Bonetti 135).
Momaday’s exceptional mastery of the language must have surprised or
even possibly intimidated a great number of non-Native writers. Regardless of the social standards, Momaday
argued that education was each individual’s right and that it should not be
restricted to the “realm of the white man” (Trimble 5). However, Momaday has since extended the
concept of education to encompass non-Indians by establishing a course solely
dedicated to the study of American Indian oral tradition at several prominent
universities (Evers 36).
Momaday’s literary achievements quickly garnered public recognition for the Native American community and provided an impetus for the renewal of the fragile bonds between generations. As the first Native American writer to ever win a national literary prize, Momaday was elevated to the position of unofficial spokesperson for all of Native America (Bruchac 96; Allen 208). Momaday’s resonant yet lucid voice finally spoke for the millions that had once been silenced. Armed with the power of publicity, Momaday established the Buffalo Trust, a non-profit organization dedicated to preserving the link between young Native Americans and the elders of the tribes (Wiegner 371). The Buffalo Trust continues to thrive today, ensuring the passage of cultural knowledge from generation to generation (Roemer par. 3).
White society’s recognition of Momaday’s talents provided the rallying force necessary to launch the era of Red Power. Although Momaday was never an outspoken politician, he supported the integration of certain Native American ideas into American policies. The most relevant suggestion was the creation of an American land ethic (Schubnell 33). In the tradition of John Muir and Aldo Leopold, Momaday called for the “extension of social ethics” to include the relationship between man and his environment (33). Momaday observed that the “Indian has always lived on the best of terms with the natural world. Western man and western European civilization has always been at odds with nature” (Costo 4-5). Momaday argued that, through an exchange of ideas, both cultures could achieve their final goal of a sustainable Earth (10).
Critics and writers agree that Momaday’s works inspired an era of renewed interest in Native American literature, more commonly known as the Native American Renaissance (“N(avarre) Scott Momaday” par. 1). Kenneth Lincoln, who originally coined the term, defined the phenomenon as a “written renewal of oral traditions translated into Western literary forms” (Lincoln 8). The 1969 Pulitzer Prize forced the dominant culture to acknowledge that twentieth-century American Indians were capable of producing written literature that was intellectually demanding and “serious” (Allen 207). Between 1968 and 1977, there was an unprecedented increase in the printing of work by Native American writers (Ruppert 173). Momaday’s influence on the Native American community is reflected in the titles of arguably the two best anthologies of American Indian writing, Carriers of the Dream Wheel and The Remembered Earth; both draw their names from Momaday’s poetry (Bruchac 110). Many Native American writers, among them Simon Ortiz and Leslie Marmon Silko, have acknowledged their literary debt to Momaday (“N(avarre) Scott Momaday” par. 1). Paula Gunn Allen has even expressed that House Made of Dawn “made things possible for [her] that were never possible before” (Bruchac 110).
N. Scott Momaday, through taps on a typewriter or scratches of a pen on paper, became a leader for the Native American people in every area, whether it be cultural, political, or literary. This man, this writer, this literary chieftain, gave a voice to Native Americans and changed the minds of Americans not with tomahawks, spears, or arrows, but with words.
Allen, Chadwick. “N.
Scott Momaday: Becoming the Bear.” The
American Nature Writers. “N(avarre) Scott Momaday.” Ed. John Elder. Vol. 2.
Bonetti, Kay. “N.
Scott Momaday: Interview.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday.
Bruchac, Joseph.
“The Magic of Words: An Interview
with N. Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott
Momaday. Ed.
Matthias Schubnell.
Costo, Rupert.
“Discussion: The Man Made of
Words.” Conversations
with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
Evers,
Lawrence J. “A Conversation with N.
Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott
Momaday. Ed.
Matthias Schubnell.
House Made of Dawn. Momaday, N. Scott.
Konevich, John.
“Momaday’s House Made of Dawn.” The Explicator. 60.4 (Summer 2002): p 236.
Literature
Resources from Gale.
Gale.
Lincoln, Kenneth. Native American Renaissance.
“Native American Cultures: Subsistence Patterns.” Encyclopedia of the American
West. 4 vols. Macmillan Reference
"Native
American Movement." Civil
Rights in the
“Native
Americans of the Plains and
“N(avarre) Scott
Momaday.” Schubnell, Matthias. Native American Writers of the
Porter, Joy. “Historical and Cultural Contexts
to Native American Literature.” The
Prampolini, Gaetano. “The Ancient Child: A Conversation with N. Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
Roemer, Kenneth M. “Vision Statement for the
Ruppert, James.
“Fiction: 1968 to the Present.” The
Scarberry-Garcia, Susan.
Landmarks of Healing: A Study of House Made of Dawn.
Schubnell, Matthias.
N. Scott Momaday: The Cultural and Literary Background.
“Shouting
at the Machine: An Interview with N.
Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
Teuton, Sean Kicummah.
Trimble, Martha Scott.
N. Scott Momaday. Western Writers Series 9.
Velie, Alan R. Four American Indian Literary
Masters.
Wiegner, Kathleen.
“N. Scott Momaday.” Page to Page: Retrospectives of Writers from the
Allen, Chadwick. “N. Scott Momaday: Becoming the Bear.” The
An essay covering Momaday’s main arguments.
American Nature
Writers. “N(avarre) Scott Momaday.”
Ed. John Elder.
Vol. 2.
An essay focusing on Momaday’s views toward nature and the environment
Bonetti, Kay.
“N. Scott Momaday:
Interview.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday.
An interview with useful quotes from critics.
Bruchac, Joseph. “The Magic of Words: An Interview with N. Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
An interview with a focus on Momaday’s impacts.
“Consumerism.”
An essay on the major causes and effects of the rise of the consumer mindset.
Costo, Rupert.
“Discussion: The Man Made of
Words.” Conversations
with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
A discussion that provided many of Momaday’s main arguments
“Ethnic Consciousness (1970s).” American Decades CD-ROM.
Gale Research, 1998. Reproduced in
A brief summary of cultural trends during the 1970s.
Evers, Lawrence J. “A Conversation with N.
Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott
Momaday. Ed.
Matthias Schubnell.
An interview with a focus on Momaday’s literary techniques
House Made of Dawn. Momaday, N. Scott.
Momaday’s main work
Isernhagen, Hartwig. Momaday,
Vizenor, Armstrong:
Conversations on American Indian Writing.
A collection of interviews with a focus on literature.
Johnson,
A work on the political and social pressures leading to the rise of Indian activism.
Konevich, John.
“Momaday’s House Made of Dawn.” The Explicator. 60.4 (Summer 2002): p 236.
Literature
Resources from Gale.
Gale.
An essay dealing with Momaday’s use of characterization.
Lincoln, Kenneth. Native
American Renaissance.
A book chronicling the rebirth of Native American literature.
“Native American Cultures:
Subsistence Patterns.” Encyclopedia of the American
West. 4
vols. Macmillan Reference
A historical essay that provided background information on Native American culture.
"Native American Movement." Civil
Rights in the
A brief historical essay on the main events of the Native American Movement
“Native Americans of the Plains and
A useful historical essay on the role of the buffalo in tribal culture.
“N(avarre) Scott
Momaday.” Schubnell, Matthias. Native American Writers of the
A biography
Roemer, Kenneth M. “Vision Statement for the
Source
for the Vision Statement of the
Porter, Joy. “Historical
and Cultural Contexts to Native American Literature.” The
A mainly historical essay focusing on American policies regarding Native Americans
Prampolini, Gaetano. “The Ancient Child: A Conversation with N. Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
A relatively newer interview with a focus on Momaday’s later works.
Ruppert, James.
“Fiction: 1968 to the Present.” The
An essay covering Native American literary trends.
"Native American Movement." Civil
Rights in the
A historical essay covering the major events of the Native American Movement.
Porter, Joy. “Historical
and Cultural Contexts to Native American Literature.” The
A historical essay on the general political and social condition of Native Americans.
Scarberry-Garcia, Susan. Landmarks
of Healing: A Study of House Made of
Dawn.
An analytical book with a focus on the cultural contexts of Abel’s recovery.
Schubnell, Matthias. N. Scott Momaday: The Cultural and Literary Background.
A comprehensive biography and study on Momaday’s non-native influences.
“Shouting at the Machine: An Interview with N. Scott Momaday.” Conversations with N. Scott Momaday. Ed. Matthias Schubnell.
An interview; source of the opening quote.
Teuton, Sean Kicummah.
An analysis of the Native American themes in House Made of Dawn
Trimble, Martha Scott. N. Scott Momaday. Western Writers Series 9.
A short pamphlet encapsulating all of Momaday’s main works and his literary style.
Velie, Alan R.
Four American
Indian Literary Masters.
A literary analysis on Momaday’s major works.
Wiegner, Kathleen. “N. Scott Momaday.” Page to
Page: Retrospectives of Writers from the
A relatively recent interview that focuses on Momaday’s latest activities.
Links
Modern American Poetry – N. Scott Momaday
Academy of Achievement Profile (biography, interview, and pictures)