Mark Twain: Satirical Social Critic and Pioneer of the
American Vernacular

Darren A. Schweitzer
Mark Twain: Satirical Social Critic and Pioneer of the American Vernacular
Thesis: Living on the Mississippi, traveling to the western United States, witnessing the Civil War, and evaluating the Gilded Age sculpted Samuel Langhorne Clemens' persona of Mark Twain, and inspired his satirical criticism of nineteenth-century American racism, imperialism, and social ideology, all central focuses of his main works. His wit, combined with his sophisticated, succinct writing method, brought an awakening of American literature, and left lasting legacies on American opinion towards social pop-culture, literary criteria, political imperialism, and egalitarian ideology.
I. Introduction
II. Biography and shaping forces of Mark Twain
A. Life on Mississippi River: steamboat pilot, boyhood adventures, printing press
B. Travels to western US: saw booming societies, mistreatment of Chinese workers, stories and tales from west, humor
C. Civil
War and implications: promoted racial equality, fought in war, did not
support social divide, removes him from
D. Post-Civil War South: disliked political greed and corruption, satires, moralist, assists and supports Grant, egalitarianism, criticizes new political structure forming, imperialism
III. Predominant arguments and rhetorical/style analysis of Mark Twain's writing and arguments
A. Mark Twain is best known for his satirical humor and critique towards racism, American imperialism, and social distinctions that bound American culture during his age. In his works, he oversteps social niceties to depict underlying American corruption.
1. Strategy: soliloquy
format criticizes empirical control in
2.
Strategy: satirizes
1. Strategy: satirizes
political and social corruption of
2. Strategy: uses Sellers character to personify this underlying corruption
D.
The Adventures of
Huckleberry Finn
1. Strategy: embodies the vulgar speech of the South to show racism, hatred, and bigotry
2. Strategy: episodic narrative, abandons formal plot structure, lacks "unities"
IV. Discussion of the legacies and impact of Mark Twain’s rhetoric: analysis and criticism
A. Popular culture: American persona, pioneer celebrity, influences other writers, "white suit"
B. Literary impacts: praise and criticism, humorist, censorship/vulgar, new satirical approach
C. Political imperialism: Reformation after Civil War, people question political corruption
D. Social ideology: racial discrimination, social abuses and advantages, equality of all men
V. Conclusion
VI. Works Cited
Mark Twain revealed in a 1906 speech as he approached the final years of his life, "I am working hard…without salary or hope of applause, upon my high and self-appointed task of reforming our national manners, and I ask for your help" (Salamo 23). In such a light-hearted context, it is a remark capable of succinctly defining the driving motives of a man whose writings revealed some of the sorest fallibilities of the crucial nineteenth century transition in American history, as he chose to "play the jester" of the age (Sloane 13). Living on the Mississippi, traveling to the western United States, witnessing the Civil War, and evaluating the Gilded Age sculpted Samuel Langhorne Clemens' persona of Mark Twain, and inspired his satirical criticism of nineteenth-century American racism, imperialism, and social ideology, all central focuses of his main works. His wit, combined with his sophisticated, succinct writing method, brought an awakening of American literature, and left lasting legacies on American opinion towards social pop-culture, literary criteria, political imperialism, and egalitarian ideology.
Mark Twain, from Life on the
As utilized so often in his works, Twain's relationship with the
nearby
the argument of black inferiority as a justification
for slavery (Fishkin
130). Twain would later concede the
negative effects of his upbringing, noting
However, the Civil War would strip Twain of, at least, physical
contact with his beloved river, as he traveled to the West to focus on his
pursuit of a literary career. The years from 1861-1866 brought
"Twain's development into [a] mature reporter who burst into national
prominence" (Sloane
4). Twain would eventually settle in
Although Twain had minimal involvement in the battles of the Civil
War, the social and political issues that the war confronted drastically
altered the direction of Twain's writing career and main arguments. The war that took 600,000 American lives
split the country with arguments over morality, and as abolitionist voices grew
louder, the
dilemma in regards to slavery ("Civil War" 6). Throughout his career, Twain
remained quite reticent on the issues of the Civil War, most likely because the
period was a moral transition for him, just as it was for the American people (Messent 4). Twain, however, was capable of distinguishing
himself from contemporaries of the time by deriving his morality from physical
perception and involving the reader with a "real speaker," an area
other realist writers chose not to pursue (Sloane 25). Racial
segregation in the aftermath of the Civil War also provided Twain
with a literary outlet through which he voiced his opinions using satirical
rhetoric, condemning the "socioeconomic class structure" of the newly
segregated South (Mitchell
2). Although he aided the
Confederacy through the Marion Rangers, a volunteer group, Twain
abstained from physical action in the war’s proceedings, but instead
constructed the basis of a literary career and surpassed fellow contemporaries
by confronting socially agitating issues with an unprecedented, satirical
boldness (Fishkin 37).
"In the aftermath of the Civil War, the South was in ruins"
with destroyed infrastructures, a new labor force, rampant governmental
corruption, and a depleted male population, and Twain
chose to sit back and satirize these ever-present flaws of the newly formulated
Southern system ("Civil
War" 6). From
1865-1876, the Reconstruction period made rapid social progression through the
Fifteenth Amendment and the Civil Rights Act, allowing black men to vote, yet
Twain realized that these movements did not eliminate substantial inter-racial
gaps within the country ("Historical Context" 2). A year and a half after the end of the war, Twain retuned to the east to cash in on the growing
journalism and literature boom (Powers 4). He also
devoted himself to aiding Ulysses S. Grant, the unguided war hero placed in the
executive office, which had created a population that exploited opportunities
to make private gain from public wealth (329). Although
"the plantation economy of the South never regained the flavor and
importance of its antebellum years," Twain observed the rebuilding,
industrializing
Mark
Twain (Powers
37).
Mark Twain is best known for his satirical humor and critique towards racism, American imperialism, and social distinctions that bound American culture during his age. In his works, he oversteps social niceties to depict underlying American corruption. "Race haunts many of Twain's writings," and the employment and pursuit of egalitarian qualities in mankind's social structure would serve an omnipresent role, while Twain progressed from his early travel writings to the imperialistic critiques of his later years (Messent 21). He extensively, and almost exclusively, used satirical and humoristic means to pursue arguments of social equality by blending preposterous, hyperbolic jokes with political satire to question the American ideology changing right before his eyes (Sloane 21). However, amongst all of his cutting critiques, Twain always remained rather evasive towards suggesting an absolute method in solving these American faults. His narrative creations were capable of defining the issues of ideal and real freedom, but in this permeating recognition of social error, Twain provided few "imaginative resolutions" (Bloom 57). This reoccurring inability stayed a constant from the transition of his mid-1800's works to his anti-imperialistic focus at the turn of the century, yet Twain's humor registered with his middle-class audience, which allowed him to strike a balance between the commonalities of American culture and the actions of the social aristocracy of the time (Fishkin 198). Thus, Twain found himself in a somewhat fortuitous circumstance in his literary career, able to rhetorically use the humor of the West, the culture of the South, and the abolitionist ideology of the North to encompass the nation as a whole in his works; he represented the full range of social classes that inhabited each region, employing an informal and colloquial writing style to allow his works to consistently progress (Sloane 22).
In his later years, while traveling abroad to Europe, and his 1905
attack on brutality in the Belgian Congo, entitled King Leopold's Soliloquy stood out in Twain's late
anti-imperialistic works, because it formulated the thoughts of a
empire-obsessed king into a ludicrously villainous interior monologue in order
to depict America’s exploitation, and therefore promotion, of oppressed
countries for economic gain (Fishkin 46). The piece
begins in a vicious outrage, as the king exclaims, "in print I get nothing
but slanders--and slanders again--and still slanders, and slanders on top of
slanders! Grant them true, what of it?
They are slanders…when uttered against a king" (King Leopold's
Soliloquy par. 1). Anaphoric
repetition of the word 'slanders' depicts King Leopold as a raging, tyrannical
oppressor, which is further emphasized when Leopold
reveals that his sole grievance is the print's challenges of his
authority. From the start, Twain has laced this work with his cutting satire, supported
by the fact that Leopold concedes that these slanders are actually true, yet
still finds them an outrageous debasement of central authority. Twain then presents the economic asphyxiation
this oppressive imperialism has caused, as the king remarks, "for twenty
years I have ruled the Congo State…barring out all foreign traders but myself;
restricting commerce to myself" (par. 3). At this point, Twain
delves into the physical reality of imperialism in the world, which uniquely
juxtaposes the hyperbolic, overly extravagant, satirical rage that King Leopold
is still enveloped in. Leopold then goes
on to criticize the papers for revealing, “…I am wiping a nation of friendless
creatures out of existence by every form of murder…and how every shilling I get
costs a rape, a mutilation or a life" (par. 4). Simply
describing the
Although less renowned than Twain's other novels, The Gilded Age, co-written with Charles
Dudley Warner in 1873, used satire
and a critical tone to depict American Reconstruction, in the aftermath of the
Civil War, as a time of corrupt and issueless politics, making the lower social
classes question the moral integrity of the aristocracy and government that was
reforming America (Gould 1). Following a Tennessee family's attempt to get
rich quick by selling their 75,000
acres of land to the federal government, Twain and
Warner's mashed together piece guides the reader through "crooked senators,
money grafting lobbyists, toadying journalists, sinister bosses, and lecherous
committee chairmen" (Powers 26). Just as in
his other works, Twain confronts his grievances from the beginning, as he
describes the main character Colonel Sellers: "The Colonel's tongue was a
magician's wand that turned dried apples into figs and water into wine as
easily as it could change a hovel into a palace and present poverty into
imminent future riches" (The Gilded Age 56). Using a metaphor and biblical reference, Twain purposely defines Sellers as a formulaic politician
with the capability of construing words for direct political advantage. Twain even gives Sellers a ludicrous
comparison to Christ's powers, yet it is effective in portraying the absolute
extent of corruption that is native to the character. Confronting scheming, underlying motives in
Although ample
credit must be given to each of Twain's literary creations throughout his
career, most of his works fail in comparison to provide the embodiment of the
nineteenth century American social criteria of rampant racism, hatred, and
bigotry that is established in The
Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
Written in the wake of Reconstruction, the novel equates the force of
pre-war black conditions to post-war, while it develops an internal, moral
struggle for Huckleberry who has bonded with the enslaved African, Jim ("Historical
Context" 2). Twain also
uses the standard, colloquial speech of the South to add a realistic aspect to
the piece and portray a shift in Huckleberry's civility from beginning to end (Abernathy 20-21). The inception of the novel shows Huckleberry
Finn as an uncivilized, uneducated child bound by the restrictions of civility
around him, as Huckleberry explains, "The Widow Douglas she took me for
her son, and allowed she would sivilize me…Then she
told me all about the bad place, and I said I wished I was there…All I wanted
was to go somewheres; all I wanted was a change" (The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn 1-3). Huckleberry's disdain for the civility of his
caretaker defines a racially unenlightened Huckleberry, still subjugated to the
civilized, yet racist population, while his desire for an abrupt change in his
life foreshadows the moral journey he will take with Jim later on in the
book. Twain is setting a comparable
precedent for the reader, while utilizing the unedited dialect of the South to
portray Huckleberry's existent ties to society.
Twain
also utilizes the Mississippi River as the main setting of the adventure,
allowing Huck to identify with it as he did as a boy as Huckleberry "laid
down in the bottom of the canoe and let her float…The sky looks ever so deep
when you lay down on your back…And how far a body can hear on the water such
nights!...I heard people talking at the ferry-landing" (35). Twain is incapable of relinquishing his
idyllic, dreamy perception of the river, yet he also shows the disruption
civilization has on its beauty in the fact that Huckleberry cannot help but
hear the voices of revelers in the night.
After Jim and Huckleberry embark on their adventure down the river,
Huckleberry reaches a moral epiphany tearing up the letter to Miss Watson
revealing Jim's location: "… I'd got to decide…betwixt two things, and I knowed it…'All right, then, I'll go to hell'…and never thought no more about reforming" (214). Huckleberry has chosen his emotional
connection over society's definition of moral standard, and thus evolved from
the racist qualities that had bound him before.
However, Twain is unable to leave the piece
with an absolute resolution to the racial struggle, because although Jim is a
freed man, Huckleberry reverts back to the same state he was in at the
beginning of the novel as he states, "Aunt Sally she's going to adopt me
and sivilize me, and I can't stand it. I been there
before" (293). Although he plans to escape society
indefinitely, Huckleberry is returned to the still-powerful society ready to
leave for another simple adventure. An
archetype of many of his works, Twain has left the reader with the moral
problem of the time, but has not provided a means to fix it (Abernathy 21).
Mark Twain in a letter to his wife Livy (Powers 615).
The effects of mass approval and celebration of his writings formed
an aspect of the writer beyond his human presence, as his life became renowned
as the epitome of a true American lifestyle.
In essence, "Twain's career presents a facade of unparalleled
success: an American dream come true" (Sloane 13). As his fame took hold throughout the world, Twain would embrace these multiple identities to create the
"white-suit" persona that established him as an early celebrity in
there was no need, because Twain's straightforward,
confrontational style was the driving force behind his fame (Fishkin 10). The public became fascinated to such an
extent, that even in his time of dire economic stress,
his former works sustained his living condition, because they were in such high
demand (Bloom 49). The masses clung to Twain's moral integrity,
not solely to his fame.
Twain also resonated as a pioneer in the early, murky waters of uncharted American literature, as he "liberated the country's imaginative history,” creating a new American vernacular by combining the miner’s slang of the West with the dialect of poor whites and Negroes in the South (Powers 5;Sloane 24). Clemens was also the first writer to use "in extended writing the fashion we all use in thinking" by inking the thoughts that first registered in his mind, without fear of repercussions of the subjects he utilized (Howells 1). As a result, some critics would denounce his as an immoral, vulgar, and uneducated writer, leading to sporadic banning of his major works (5). However, Twain still preserved his legacy as a literary comic. Instead of intensively focusing on the undesirable and detestable conditions of social minorities, Twain shifted his point of view to form a new literary approach, mocking the notion of honor that their oppressors commonly held for themselves (Abernathy 49).
Twain's struggle with globally expanding imperialism in his later
years may have not upended the movement, in light of current events, but his
determined pursuit caused the public to heed his warning of imperialistic evils
(Sloane 20). In this aspect of his arguments, Twain was readily involved as a participant in the
Anti-Imperialist League that opposed the new direction of the
Twain's literary pursuit of social egalitarianism would reverberate throughout American culture, and even strengthen racial equality beyond the extent of the black and white conflict within the Unites States. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn has sparked ongoing debates that have lasted 120 years, generating deep passion and opinion for human equality (Abernathy 17). Twain's realistic, individualistic, unifying vision created ideal capabilities for the popular reader, sparking the pursuit of improvement among social lines (Sloane 25-27). This encompassing view point has also had an effect in transnational relations, because Twain's fame abroad helps to bond the American social ideal with views of foreign nations (Messent 115). Not only has Twain lessened racial chasms, but he has also struck a balance amongst the upper, middle, and lower social classes by providing ample representations of each in his works (Fishkin 197).
Twain's works may have solely defined the
Abernathy, Jeff. To Hell and Back: Race and Betrayal in the
Southern Novel.
Bloom, Harold.
Bloom's Biocritiques: MarkTwain.
Bush, Harold K, Jr. Mark Twain and the Spiritual Crisis of his Age.
"Civil War and
Reconstruction." DISCovering
Clemens, S.L. King Leopold's Soliloquy. A Defense of His
Fishkin, Shelley Fisher., ed. A Historical Guide to Mark Twain.
Flanagan,
William G. "Mark Twain is your
Pilot." Forbes 155.u11 (May
22, 1995): 286(3). General One File. Gale.
Gould,
Lewis L. "Gilded Age." The
Historical Context:
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn." EXPLORING Novels.
Howells,
W.D. "Criticism by W.D. Howells." DISCovering Authors. Online ed.
Messent, Peter. The
Mitchell, Thomas G. Antislavery Politics: in Antebellum and
Civil War
Powers, Ron.
Mark Twain: A Life.
Salamo,
Lin., ed, and Victor Fischer, and Michael B.
Frank. Mark Twain's Helpful Hints for
Good Living.
Sloane, David E.E. Student Companion to Mark Twain.
Twain, Mark. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
---.
The Gilded
Age.
Watkins, T.H. Mark Twain's
Abernathy, Jeff. To
Hell and Back: Race and Betrayal in the Southern Novel.
Abernathy analyzes arguments of racism and segregation within classic American works. His specific inclusion of Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn contributed strategies and legacies.
Bender, David L., pub. Slavery: Opposing Viewpoints.
A topical book confronting abolitionist and sectionalist view points towards slavery during the Civil War.
Bloom, Harold. Bloom's
Biocritiques: MarkTwain.
A main source that analyzed Twain's specific literary text, quotes, and arguments.
Bush, Harold K, Jr. Mark Twain and the Spiritual Crisis of his Age.
A source analyzing religious influences on Twain, and how these teaching affected his moral arguments.
“The Character of Jim and the Ending of Huckleberry Finn.” DISCovering Authors. Online ed.
Short essay analysis of character interactions in the The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
"Civil War and Reconstruction." DISCovering
Providing factual evidence of changing politics in the time proceeding the Civil War.
Clemens, S.L. King Leopold's Soliloquy. A Defense of His
One of the works utilized in the second movement. One of Twain's prominent anti-imperialistic works.
Copp, Darlene P. "
A physical description of Civil War influence in the South.
Dempsey, Terrell. Searching for Jim: Slavery in Sam Clemen's
World.
Rhetorical analysis of Twain's anti-slavery views and the influences that caused him to show opinions on the matter.
Fishkin, Shelley Fisher., ed. A Historical Guide to
Mark Twain.
A work that provided analysis of Twain's historical significance. Aided the third legacies movement.
Flanagan, William
G. "Mark Twain is your
Pilot." Forbes 155.u11 (May
22, 1995): 286(3). General One File. Gale.
A descriptive
narrative describing the physical features of the
Gould, Lewis
L. "Gilded
Age." The
A historical reference for the economic, political, and social trends proceeding the Civil War.
"Historical
Context: The Adventures of Huckleberry
Finn." EXPLORING
Novels.
An analysis of the historical significance of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
Howells, W.D.
"Criticism by W.D. Howells." DISCovering Authors.
Online ed.
An analytical critique on Twain's literary works and the arguments they encompassed.
Johnson, Claudia Durst.
Understanding Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
A work defining the arguments and literary structure of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
"Mark Twain."
Biography. A&E Home Video.
A short video introduction to the life of Mark Twain.
Mensh, Elaine, and Harry Mensh. Black, White, and
Huckleberry Finn.
Analysis of racial arguments in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
Messent, Peter. The
Biography and contextual relevance of Mark Twain's life and career.
Mitchell, Thomas G. Antislavery
Politics: in Antebellum and Civil War
A political analysis of antislavery policies in the North and South.
Powers, Ron. Mark
Twain: A Life.
A main source analyzing specific aspects of Mark Twain's life from his birth to his death. Also provided many of Twain's quotations.
Salamo, Lin., ed,
and Victor Fischer, and Michael B. Frank.
Mark Twain's Helpful Hints for Good Living.
Provided a main quotation to begin the piece.
Sloane, David E.E. Student Companion to Mark Twain.
A biography and literary analysis of Mark Twain and his works.
Trombley, Laura E. Skandera., ed., and Michael J.
Kiskis.
Constructing Mark Twain.
A somewhat biased novel criticizing minor nuances of Twain's career.
Twain, Mark. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
The main literary work of the paper. Encompasses Twain's significant racial arguments.
---. The Adventures of Tom Sawyer.
A considering literary work that was later denied.
---. The Gilded Age.
The second literary work of the second movement. Exemplifies Twain's sharp
criticism of the reconstruction
---. The Innocents Abroad/Roughing It.
A considering literary work that was later denied.
---. Life on the
A considering literary work that was later denied.
Watkins, T.H. Mark
Twain's
Showed Twain's bond with the
Links